Crime & Traffic

Worried about doing this on your own?  You may be able to get free legal help.

Part of the Legal Professionals library, sponsored by Quilling, Selander, Lownds, Winslett & Moser.

Logo for Quilling, Selander, Lownds, Winslett & Moser

What to know if you think Chicago police violated your rights

Police misconduct, as defined by Illinois law, 720 ILCS 5/33-9 includes when a police officer:

  • Misrepresents or fails to provide facts,        
  • Withholds any knowledge of the misrepresentations of another law enforcement officer, or
  • Fails follow state law or department policy on wearing body cameras. 

The sentence for law enforcement misconduct is a Class 3 felony, but it is incredibly rare that any officer will be charged for this conduct.

But police misconduct lawsuits are civil, not criminal. This means you are suing private individuals, like police officers, and public bodies, as opposed to a criminal case, where the state is “suing” you in the form of a prosecution.

Common grounds for a civil police misconduct lawsuit involve violations of the Constitution. For example, the following circumstances could give rise to a police misconduct lawsuit: 

  • Excessive use of force against you by a police officer;
  • A police officer stopped you without probable cause or reasonable suspicion, but did not arrest you;
  • An arrest or search without probable cause;
  • A police officer caused you to be prosecuted without probable cause;
  • Discrimination by a police officer against you based on your race, gender, or membership in another “protected class”; or
  • Behavior by a police officer that was so outrageous that it “shocks the conscience” in violation of due process rights.

A civil case places the burden on you to prove certain things. You must prove that: 

  • Your account of the events is more likely than not what actually occurred (the defendants, naturally, will tell a different story), and
  • Your rights under the constitution were violated.
There is time built into the process of filing a lawsuit called "discovery." This is where the parties exchange information to learn more about the events at issue and allows you to: 
  • Investigate and back up your assertions by obtaining records and statements from third parties,
  • Ask police officers questions under oath, both in writing and in an extended interview called a “deposition,” and
  • Hire an expert to help strengthen your claims.

It is important to remember that the discovery process goes both ways. Just like you get to ask the defendants questions, they get to do the same for you. This process can feel, and often is, very invasive. For example, because you brought the lawsuit and likely claimed that you were injured either physically or emotionally, your past medical history is often fair game for examination.

Your investigation can include police records. Private and public police records about complaints, investigations, and misconduct can't be destroyed. These records have to be permanently maintained.

A police misconduct lawsuit does not mean a police officer gets sent to prison, or even subjected to any professional discipline. Not every police misconduct case is the same, and sadly, not every violation of your civil rights is considered a desirable case for lawyers.
See the Enforce Your Rights Manual for more information. This guide is not a substitute for a lawyer. It should give you some ground rules for what to do and what to expect in police misconduct cases. You can contact First Defense Legal Aid at 1-800-LAW-REP4 (529-7374) to be placed in contact with civil rights attorneys in FDLA’s Clinic who can consider your potential case. 
 
Last full review by a subject matter expert
October 23, 2023
Last revised by staff
November 07, 2023

Comments & Ratings

Rate
No votes yet

Only logged-in users can post comments.  Please log in or register if you want to leave a comment.  We do our best to reply to each comment. We can't give legal advice in the comments, so if you have a question or need legal help, please go to Get Legal Help.

Worried about doing this on your own?  You may be able to get free legal help.

Part of the Legal Professionals library, sponsored by Quilling, Selander, Lownds, Winslett & Moser.

Logo for Quilling, Selander, Lownds, Winslett & Moser